Infection
November 20th was a significant anniversary for me, because both my mother and her father (back in Cape Breton, Nova Scotia) were born on this day. It takes no exceptional effort to die on a particular day — indeed usually it ‘just happens” — but to be born requires an “Act of God,” that is quite impossible for us. That is why the Christians prefer to celebrate deaths, and mark them in our calendars. Deaths are much more human.
Leo Tolstoy, for instance, died on November 20th (new style), in 1910. I was reading his tractate, What is Art? — this morning, and recalling a previous encounter, a long time ago. That was when I first congratulated the author for his escape from the cult of beauty. Instead, he finds that the true artist performs an act of communion with the true reader, or an act of emotional and moral transmission, entirely bypassing beauty. He spreads an infection.
He does not merely communicate good taste, or “elitism,” but instead something more human, and consequential, by which we might learn to read or write in turn — or draw, sing, dance.
Alternatively, we leave these activities to machines, and to “content” which is empty.
A machine cannot infect a human, or even infect another machine. But a human can do it, heroically, when he has mastered the difficult techniques of his art. This does not mean that a man cannot do what the machine can do, unheroically, although rather more precisely. Most published works are (of course) useless trash, because they are by humans trying to emulate machines, and manipulating even dramatic events and artistic spectacles according to some easy formula. Thanks to YouTube, one can become a dedicated consumer of such things, retaining less the more one consumes.
Tolstoy recommends, to one who wishes to understand a difficult book, that he start by assimilating what is clear in it, then gradually extending to what is less clear; or discovering that it is, like the Koran, quite incoherent. Nevertheless, if it is not fundamentally incoherent, he may eventually understand it. This is the method of reading, or seeing, &c, in the wrong order. It is why almost any narrative work, even a ballad or a tale, is better than a novel, and harder to write, whether it is long or short.. (In the days when ballads were composed, sincerity was more common.)
With the triumph of the Internet, art has become more and more mechanical and inhuman. Soon there will be no reason for an actual person to consult it, at all.